4651 Castalia CT
Fort Myers, FL 33905
$950,000
Welcome to Horse Creek - one of SWFL's only remaining old Florida-style gated communities nestled on the Orange River. Enjoy peace & serenity here without sacrificing everyday life conveniences. Sitting on a sprawling 1 acre lot with 8 fruit trees on the property -1 pomegranate, 2 avocado, 1 lime, 2 lemon, and 2 fig trees. This custom built, luxurious French-Colonial style concrete block home finished in Santa Barbara stucco offers a soft, elegant texture rarely found in modern Florida construction. With a brand new standing seam metal roof and a location in flood zone X (flood insurance not required) you can have peace of mind. The lot can accommodate a future outbuilding to store your RV, boat, or simply to have an incredible workshop or she-shed. The interior features 4 bedrooms(2 of the guest rooms are en-suite and 1 has a large walk in closet)+ den with closet, 3 full bathrooms, and many upgrades like a beautiful kitchen with granite counters, stainless steel appliances and a reverse osmosis faucet, tile throughout the main living areas, and plush carpet in the bedrooms, along with a private sitting area in the master bedroom. Enjoy the sounds of built in ceiling speakers located in the living room, Master Bedroom, and Lanai. The large 3 car garage with 220v outlet for electric vehicle charging gives plenty of space for your toys, and vehicles. The oversized outdoor lanai features hurricane shutters, an elegant custom pool ...
+ Read More| Listing ID: | 226027985 |
|---|---|
| List Price: | $975,000 |
| Close Price: | $950,000 |
| Close Date: | 2026-11-09 |
| Property Type: | Residential |
| Property Sub Type: | Single Family Residence |
| Status: | Sold |
| Bedrooms Total: | 4 |
| Bathrooms Full: | 3 |
| Bathrooms Half: | 0 |
| Living Area: | 2,671 |
| Association Fee: | $1,660 |
| Tax Annual Amount: | $3,807 |
| Lot Size Square Feet: | 43,560 |
| Lot Size Acres: | 1.0 |
| Architectural Style: | Ranch, Single Family |
| Waterfront?: | No |
| City: | Fort Myers |
| County Or Parish: | Lee |
| Subdivision Name: | Horse Creek |
| Postal Code: | 33905 |
| Year Built: | 2006 |
| Number Of Units Total: | 1 |
| Equipment: | Auto Garage Door, Cooktop, Cooktop - Electric, Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Microwave, Refrigerator/Freezer, Refrigerator/Icemaker, Reverse Osmosis, Washer |
| Cooling: | Central Electric |
| Flooring: | Carpet, Tile, Wood |
| Heating: | Central Electric |
| Lot Features: | Oversize |
| Parking Features: | Attached |
| Pool Features: | Below Ground, Custom Upgrades, Electric Heat |
| Status: | Closed |
| State Or Province: | FL |
| Water Source: | Reverse Osmosis - Partial House, Well |
| Pool Private?: | Yes |
| Roof: | Metal |
| Spa Features: | Below Ground, Heated Electric |
| Laundry Features: | Laundry in Residence, Laundry Tub |
| Foundation Details: | Concrete Block |
| Construction Materials: | Concrete Block, Stucco |
| Cooling?: | Yes |
| Fireplace?: | No |
| Garage?: | Yes |
| Heating?: | Yes |
| Lot Size Area: | 1 |
| Association Amenities: | Park, Fishing Pier, Play Area, Streetlight, Underground Utility |
| Attached Garage?: | Yes |
| Building Area Total: | 3842 |
| Carport?: | No |
| Community Features: | Park, Fishing, Street Lights, Gated |
| Door Features: | French Doors |
| Exterior Features: | Screened Lanai/Porch, Built-In Wood Fire Pit |
| Interior Features: | Bar, French Doors, Laundry Tub, Smoke Detectors |
| Levels: | 1 |
| Living Area Units: | Square Feet |
| Lot Size Units: | Acres |
| MLS Area Major: | HORSE CREEK |
| New Construction?: | No |
| Parking Total: | 3 |
| Patio And Porch Features: | Patio |
| Security Features: | Gated Community, Smoke Detector(s) |
| Sewer: | Septic Tank |
| Waterfront Features: | None |
| Horse?: | No |
| View: | Landscaped Area |
| View?: | Yes |
| Covered Spaces: | 3 |
| Elementary School: | SCHOOL CHOICE |
| Furnished: | Unfurnished |
| Garage Spaces: | 3 |
| High School: | SCHOOL CHOICE |
| Middle Or Junior School: | SCHOOL CHOICE |
| Pets Allowed: | Yes |
| Structure Type: | House |
| Appliances: | Cooktop, Electric Cooktop, Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Microwave, Refrigerator/Freezer, Refrigerator/Icemaker, Reverse Osmosis, Washer |
| Association?: | Yes |
| Bathrooms Total Integer: | 3 |
| Lease Term: | Buyer Finance/Cash |
| Original List Price: | $985,000 |
| Senior Community?: | No |
| Spa?: | Yes |
| Building Area Units: | Square Feet |
| Irrigation Source: | Well |
| Listing Contract Date: | 2026-08-03 |
| Additional RoomsNabor Additional Rooms: | Den - Study, Laundry in Residence, Screened Lanai/Porch |
| Bedrooms: | 4+Den |
| Boat Access: | None |
| Building Desc: | 1 Story/Ranch |
| Cdom: | 98 |
| Canal Width: | None |
| Community Type: | Gated |
| Contingency Type: | Sale of Home |
| Dom: | 48 |
| Elevator: | None |
| Floor Plan Type: | Great Room |
| Foreclosed REO: | No |
| Gas Yn: | No |
| Golf Type: | No Golf Available |
| Gulf Access Yn: | No |
| Kitchen Description: | Walk-In Pantry |
| Last Change Timestamp: | 2026-11-09T16:00:03.650Z |
| Lease Limits Yn: | Yes |
| Leases Per Year: | 2 |
| List Price: | $975,000.00 |
| Lot Back: | 155 |
| Lot Frontage: | 155 |
| Lot Left: | 279 |
| Lot Right: | 282 |
| Mls Area Major: | Bu01 - Buckingham |
| Maintenance: | Legal/Accounting, Manager |
| Management: | Professional |
| Master Hoa Fee: | $415.00 |
| Master Hoa Fee Freq: | Quarterly |
| Min Days of Lease: | 30 |
| Num Unit Floor: | 1 |
| Owner Name: | COSGROVE FAMILY TRUST |
| Ownership Desc: | Single Family |
| Potential Short Sale Yn: | No |
| Rear Exposure: | E |
| Restrictions: | Architectural, Deeded, No Commercial, No RV |
| Status Type: | Resale Property |
| Storm Protection: | Impact Resistant Doors, None, Shutters Electric |
| Table: | Residential |
| Units in Complex: | 113 |
| Room Bedroom Features: | First Floor Bedroom, Master BR Ground, Split Bedrooms |
| Room Dining Room Features: | Dining - Family |
| Stories Total: | 1 |
| Tax Year: | 2025 |
| Park Name: | HORSE CREEK |
Listing Courtesy of: Premiere Plus Realty Company
(239) 908-1310
Buyer Represented by: Compass Florida LLC
Mortgage Calculator
The data relating to real estate for sale displayed on this Website comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program (BR Program) of Naples Area Board of REALTORS®, under License No. NPLSMLS-100139. Properties listed with brokerage firms other than North 2 South Realty International Inc are marked with the "BR House" logo. Detailed information about such properties includes the name of the brokerage firm with which the seller has listed the property. The properties displayed may not be all the properties listed with brokerage firms participating in the Naples Area Board of REALTORS®. BR Program, or contained in the database compilation of the Naples Area Board of REALTORS®.
Naples Area Board of REALTORS® data last updated on November 10, 2026 02:21 AM - ET
Property Last Updated: November 10, 2026 02:21 AM - ET


















































