There are only a select few offerings along Florida’s Gulf Coast that can be described as irreplaceable. This extraordinary bayfront estate on Sanibel Island stands firmly among them. On approximately 1.6 acres, this is one of the largest buildable bayfront parcels on Sanibel Island, distinguished not only by its scale, but by its exceptional east-end location near the historic Sanibel Lighthouse. Tucked away at the end of private Buttonwood Lane, the property enjoys a rare sense of seclusion while remaining just a short distance to Sanibel’s world-renowned white sand beaches and moments from convenient on-and-off island access. The estate boasts approximately 150 feet of direct bay frontage, where gentle shoreline sands meet the shimmering waters of San Carlos Bay. A new private dock extends gracefully into the bay, offering immediate boating access and an ever-changing panorama of sunrises, passing vessels and coastal wildlife, also an ideal gateway for boating, paddleboarding or sunset cruises. Beyond its natural beauty, the property’s distinction lies in its extraordinary development potential. According to the City of Sanibel Planning Department (Development Permit88-7456), the parcel is allocated three dwelling units within the D2 – Upland Wetlands ecological zone, with a minimum lot size of 15,000 square feet. The generous acreage allows for subdivision into three single-family parcels, presenting a spectrum of possibilities from a legacy bayfront compound to an intimate enclave of luxury residences, or a singular estate of remarkable scale and presence. Opportunities of this caliber, ...
+ Read More| Listing ID: | 2026047943 |
|---|---|
| List Price: | $9,600,000 |
| Property Type: | Land |
| Status: | Active |
| Bathrooms Half: | 0 |
| Tax Annual Amount: | $20,725 |
| Lot Size Square Feet: | 69,696 |
| Lot Size Acres: | 1.6 |
| Waterfront?: | Yes |
| City: | Sanibel |
| County Or Parish: | Lee |
| Subdivision Name: | Metes And Bounds |
| Postal Code: | 33957 |
| Lot Features: | Across From Waterfront, Oversize, See Remarks |
| Status: | Active |
| State Or Province: | FL |
| Water Source: | Central |
| Fireplace?: | No |
| Garage?: | No |
| Lot Size Area: | 1.6 |
| Attached Garage?: | No |
| Carport?: | No |
| Exterior Features: | Boat Dock Private |
| Frontage Type: | Bay/Harbor |
| Living Area Units: | Square Feet |
| Lot Size Units: | Acres |
| MLS Area Major: | METES AND BOUNDS |
| New Construction?: | No |
| Utilities: | Other |
| Waterfront Features: | Bay |
| Horse?: | No |
| View: | Bay |
| View?: | Yes |
| Current Use: | 01-Single Family |
| Parcel Number: | 21-46-23-T1-00001.0000 |
| Structure Type: | House |
| Association?: | No |
| Electric On Property?: | No |
| Lease Term: | Buyer Finance/Cash |
| Original List Price: | $9,600,000 |
| Possible Use: | Other/See Remarks, Single Family, Residential |
| Road Surface Type: | Gravel |
| Senior Community?: | No |
| Building Area Units: | Square Feet |
| Irrigation Source: | Central |
| Listing Contract Date: | 2026-11-16 |
| Boat Access: | Boat Dock Private |
| Cdom: | 1 |
| Canal Width: | Canal Width 200+ |
| Community Type: | Non-Gated |
| Dom: | 1 |
| Foreclosed REO: | No |
| Gulf Access Type: | No Bridge(s)/Water Direct |
| Gulf Access Yn: | Yes |
| Last Change Timestamp: | 2026-11-16T21:42:48.400Z |
| Legal Desc: | PAR IN SEC 20 + 21 DESC IN OR1822 PGS2457 + 2455 W OF BUTTONWOOD RD |
| Legal Unit: | N/A |
| List Price: | $9,600,000.00 |
| Lot Back: | 159 |
| Lot Frontage: | 149 |
| Lot Left: | 426 |
| Lot Right: | 363 |
| Lot Type: | Residential Lot |
| Lot Unit: | N/A |
| Mls Area Major: | Si01 - Sanibel Island |
| Owner Name: | Jean Hoyt Olinger |
| Potential Short Sale Yn: | No |
| Range: | 23E |
| Rear Exposure: | N |
| Restrictions: | None/Other |
| Section: | 21 |
| Table: | Lot & Land |
| Township: | 46 |
| Tax Year: | 2024 |
| Park Name: | METES AND BOUNDS |
Listing Courtesy of: Premier Sotheby's Int'l Realty
(239) 464-2984
Mortgage Calculator
The data relating to real estate for sale displayed on this Website comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program (BR Program) of Naples Area Board of REALTORS®, under License No. NPLSMLS-100139. Properties listed with brokerage firms other than North 2 South Realty International Inc are marked with the "BR House" logo. Detailed information about such properties includes the name of the brokerage firm with which the seller has listed the property. The properties displayed may not be all the properties listed with brokerage firms participating in the Naples Area Board of REALTORS®. BR Program, or contained in the database compilation of the Naples Area Board of REALTORS®.
Naples Area Board of REALTORS® data last updated on November 18, 2026 02:59 PM - ET
Property Last Updated: November 18, 2026 02:59 PM - ET

